‘Frustrated’ California family says insurer dropped them without warning due to aerial photos of 500-year-old oak tree on their property — and it would cost them $40K to remove it

Insurance companies are increasingly relying on aerial photos

The use of aerial photos to inspect properties has been on the rise in recent years. These photos allow insurance companies to assess the condition of a property and identify potential risks. "This is nothing new, as far as looking at homes and looking at properties at renewal," insurance expert Karl Susman told CBS. "It's just the idea feels a little bit awkward and a little weird and strange to have, you know, not know when it's happening," said Susman.

Safeco argues that aerial photos are a useful tool for identifying issues that might go unnoticed. A Safeco spokesperson told the television station, “We cannot comment on an individual customer, but we have to understand the condition of the property, and satellite imagery is useful to identify issues we and homeowners otherwise don't know exist.”

While the use of drones, satellites, and planes to take aerial photos is efficient, it also raises concerns with homeowners. Third-party aerial imagery services often leave consumers in the dark about how their property is being evaluated. Additionally, decisions based on these images can be inaccurate or lack the context an on-site evaluation would provide.

For the Heieck-Toms, that context includes the resources they've invested in ensuring the tree's health.

"We really consider ourselves the custodians of this tree," said Liz Heieck-Toms. For decades the couple have worked with a tree expert to maintain the tree. "When we got here, the canopy was over the top of the house," said Will. "... we've taken probably 40-50% of this tree away.”

The Heieck-Toms have until December to find a new insurance provider, and it's not been easy, with one company offering "half the amount of coverage for almost three times the price."

"I feel like the insurance companies are just using things like this as an excuse because they don't want to be insuring homes in California because of all the fires and stuff," said Liz.

Stop overpaying for home insurance

Home insurance is an essential expense – one that can often be pricey. You can lower your monthly recurring expenses by finding a more economical alternative for home insurance.

Officialhomeinsurance can help you do just that. Their online marketplace of vetted home insurance providers allows you to quickly shop around for rates from the country’s top insurance companies, and ensure you’re paying the lowest price possible for your home insurance.

Explore better rates

What homeowners can do

If you're a homeowner facing a non-renewal notice from your insurance company, the situation can be scary and overwhelming. However, there are several steps you can take to protect your home and possibly maintain coverage.

Homeowners should immediately contact their insurance company and request detailed information or the specific images used to make the non-renewal decision. Understanding the exact issue and speaking with the insurance company will determine your next steps.

Correct any inaccuracies with the insurance company. Aerial images can sometimes misinterpret features or fail to capture recent updates or changes to the property. For example, photos taken just after a storm might show debris on a roof that was later removed.

Finally, make sure you understand your rights. For instance, in California, insurers must notify you at least 75 days before your policy expires. They also cannot cancel your policy if it has a guaranteed renewal provision or if you live in an area adjacent to a recent wildfire. If your insurer has not followed the regulations or you feel like the non-renewal is unfair, you should report it to the authorities.

Don't wait too long to shop for a new insurance plan since it could take longer than you expect.