This Florida HOA allowed a towing company to enter private driveways, haul vehicles with expired tags in the dead of night — residents slam it as an ‘abuse of power.’ Do they have a point?

Were the towings valid?

HOA Attorney Kathleen Reres represents the community Wells lives in and told ABC Action News it did sign a contract with A-1 Recovery to enforce parking laws. She believes the HOA had a right to allow the company to enforce parking restrictions outlined in the contract, but it was signed years ago.

"Whether it’s a good idea is an entirely different issue,” Reres said.

Two nights after towing Wells’ truck, the A-1 Recovery drivers were confronted by neighbors while attempting to tow a Tesla, which was still plugged into the owner's house.

Allison Shaw, an ABC Action News photographer and the owner of the vehicle, insisted they drop her family's car — but they’d only do so for a $75 fee.

Pasco County Sheriff’s deputies arrived shortly after and told the tow truck drivers they had no authority to be there and that towing any vehicle would be considered theft.

According to ABC Action News, two days after reporters spoke with neighbors in the community, the HOA suspended towing services with A-1 Recovery.

Discover how a simple decision today could lead to an extra $1.3 million in retirement

Learn how you can set yourself up for a more prosperous future by exploring why so many people who work with financial advisors retire with more wealth.

Discover the full story and see how you could be on the path to an extra $1.3 million in retirement.

Read More

Is towing cars on private property an abuse of power?

This incident has raised questions about the HOA's authority and how far towing companies can go to enforce its rules. In Florida, HOAs typically have the authority to oversee property maintenance, including parking regulations.

However, the HOA’s jurisdiction over private driveways is a point of contention. According to videos provided to ABC Action News, the A-1 Recovery company employees argued they were hired to enforce the community's rules regarding expired tags, as outlined in the neighborhood's covenants.

While towing companies typically operate under strict guidelines, residents seemed unaware that a towing company had even been contracted to monitor their driveways.

Wells told reporters he waited two hours for someone to release his impounded truck and missed a full morning of classes at the National Aviation Academy. And for residents whose vehicles were towed, it’s more than just the inconvenience.

The cost of retrieving a car that was towed from private property can range between roughly $150 to $400, depending on how long the car is impounded. Wells had to pay more than $200.

“That’s my grocery money for the month,” he said.

These fines can create a significant burden, especially for residents with tight budgets. Fortunately, Florida recently passed a bill aimed at reforming the tow truck industry and limiting predatory actions.